Reel Classics > Commentary
> Reviews >
Movie Reviews
Films listed by Year | Films listed by Title | Films listed by Rank
-
Some weaknesses, but overall a decent film.
dir. Richard Thorpe at MGM
with Fred Astaire (as
Bert Kalmar), Red Skelton (as Harry Ruby), Vera-Ellen
(as Jessie Brown Kalmar), Arlene Dahl (as Eileen Percy Ruby), Keenan Wynn
(as Charlie Kope), Gale Robbins (Terry Lordel), Gloria De Haven (as Mrs.
Carter De Haven) and Debbie
Reynolds (as Helen Kane) |
This film is a musical biopic of songwriters Bert Kalmar
and Harry Ruby, and it's chockfull of some of their best numbers including
"Where Did You Get That Girl?", "Nevertheless", and
"I Wanna Be Loved by You." With stars like Astaire
and Vera-Ellen,
you know you’re sure to see some entertaining dances, and numbers like
"Thinking of You" and "Mr. and Mrs. Hoofer at Home",
though they’re not as wonderful as they could be, don’t disappoint
either. Plot-wise there’s nothing terribly noteworthy except the team’s
breakup, but enough happens to keep the picture moving between the musical
numbers.
Overall, if you like Astaire
and Vera-Ellen,
you’ll like them together in this film. It’s also worth watching for
the soundtrack which includes a couple dozen songs by this famous
song-writing team. Worthy of further note are Arlene Dahl, who is well
suited to her role, and Debbie
Reynolds, who makes her screen debut in this film, dancing a brief
sequence in "I Wanna Be Loved by You" (though her Betty Boop
voice was dubbed by the real Helen Kane).
Reviewed: December 24, 1999 |
Films
listed by Year | Films
listed by Title | Films
listed by Rank |